Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Steven Newcomb's avatar

Greetings John,

Thanks for sharing your information about the "Kinship Worldview" that is being advanced by Ms. Narvaez and Four Arrows (aka Don Jacobs), which is what the followers of the Wolakot/Woope Worldview call in English "All Our [My] Relations." I'm sure they are doing good work.

English is such an interesting language isn't it? It sometimes seems to create a gravitational pull toward conflict, than a pull toward meeting one another in a collaborative manner. Choosing to not engage with the ideas expressed in a particular essay strikes me as a peculiar response to a piece of writing. We might call it a "non-response response." That being said, I find it odd that nowhere in your statement do you use the word "domination," despite my Substack being titled "The Domination Chronicles" and despite me using the word or a variation thereof at least 18 times in my "Dreaming the World" article.

You suggest that I have "vilified" the "west" but given that my article is focused on challenging patterns of domination and the claim of a right of domination, wouldn't it have been more on target to suggest that I am guilty of vilifying domination and the claim of a right of domination? Vilify is such an interesting choice of words, "To make vile, debase, degrade, to debase by report, to defame, See Malign." Also, "To speak evil of" [domination]. But, come to think of it, some readers might consider it bizarre to criticize someone for writing negatively about domination.

You've evidently assessed my article and decided that I've also ignored "our shared history [of] thousands of generations," and thereby engaged in an "unscientific exercise of shame/blame," while demonstrating "self-righteous posturing," albeit perhaps "inadvertently." You say that "we" (me, I?) "need to stop" taking this "unscientific" approach "and find ways to restore those tried and true ways of living," despite the ongoing existence of the domination system and its claim of a right of domination, which makes such a restoration, to a great extent, rather untenable, or only tenable in a context of on ongoing and unceasing system of domination.

And, after all this, you've generously promoted the book of your friends "Restoring the Kinship Worldview." As if to say "forget about all this domination talk. Look over there, for that's where the truly important information is to be found." In any case, thanks for reaching out. I do appreciate it.

Expand full comment
John Stuckey's avatar

I think it's important to acknowledge/understand that we ALL shared what Darcia Narvaez and Wahinkpe Topa (Four Arrows/Don Jacobs) referred to as the 'Kinship Worldview,' until the plague of 'Civilization' came to create the various systems of hierarchy under which we all suffer. The surpluses which totalitarian agriculture produced led to those hierarchical structures, but our species spent all but the last 10-20 (still being investigated) thousand years living with various examples of that view of the world and our places in it. Vilifying the 'west,' while ignoring our shared history, thousands of generations, turns the discussion into an unscientific exercise of shame/blame. We all need to stop with the self-righteous posturing, no matter how inadvertent, and find ways to restore those tried and true ways of living. The full title of the book I referenced is 'Restoring the Kinship Worldview,' and I highly recommend it.

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts